SchoolTube Community
Have you ever stopped to think about what makes you, you? Or what makes your favorite coffee mug your favorite? It might seem like a simple question, but it leads us down a rabbit hole of philosophical pondering about identity. And who better to guide us on this journey than the Caped Crusader himself?
Let's start with a brain teaser: Is Batman simply Bruce Wayne in a fancy costume, or are they distinct entities? You might say Bruce Wayne is the essence of Batman – the trauma, the drive for justice – it's all there. But then along comes Dick Grayson, the original Robin, donning the cowl in Bruce's absence. Is he Batman too? What about when Commissioner Gordon took up the mantle? Suddenly, the lines get blurry.
This is where the Indiscernibility of Identicals comes in, a principle proposed by philosopher Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz. It states that if two things are truly identical, they must share all the same properties. Bruce Wayne enjoys lavish parties and has a soft spot for orphaned vigilantes – Batman, not so much. Different properties, different identities.
Think of it like the Ship of Theseus. If, over time, every plank of wood on the ship is replaced, is it still the same ship? Each replacement introduces a new property, subtly shifting its identity. The same goes for us. We change, we grow, we spill coffee on our favorite shirt, acquiring new properties along the way. Does that make us fundamentally different?
To grapple with this, philosophers use the concepts of essential and accidental properties. Essential properties are the core, defining traits of a thing. Accidental properties, as the name suggests, are more like accessories. Your dog losing its tail in a freak frisbee accident is unfortunate but doesn't change the fact that it's still your dog. But what are the essential properties of a dog? Or a human, for that matter? That's where things get really interesting.
Some philosophers, like the existentialists, throw their hands up and say there's no such thing as an essential property. Everything is in flux, constantly changing, like Heraclitus's ever-flowing river. You can't step in the same river twice, and you can't be the same 'you' twice either.
So, what does this all mean for us non-philosophers? Well, it makes us question the things we value and why. Is your favorite coffee mug special because of its unique design, or is it the memories you associate with it? If it breaks and you get an identical replacement, is it truly the same mug?
This is where the idea of fungibility comes in – the interchangeability of objects. Money is fungible – a ten-dollar bill is a ten-dollar bill, regardless of its individual history. But a hand-knitted scarf from your grandmother? Not so much.
Ultimately, the philosophy of identity is a journey of exploration, with no easy answers. It encourages us to look beyond the surface, to question our assumptions, and to appreciate the complex tapestry of experiences that make us who we are – ever-changing, yet always ourselves.
You may also like